So let's start this off on a good note I LOVE ASH FUR HE IS BABY But the new ash fur is evil,careless and cruel AshFur was NEVER and I repeat NEVER like that sure he was mad with greif he threatened to kill leaf pool and crow feathers kits which everyone thought where squirrel flights, and what she did to him was unfair and cruel but he had no reason to hate thunder clan, he was the loyalists warrior their was at the time, so you may ask " then why did the Erin's do that?" Well hears the awnser because they could, they could have made it, tigerstar, hawkfrost, Mapleshade, thistle claw or even dark tail! But NO it haddddd to be ash fur poor old ash fur and when he entered starclan he changed he became friends with Hollyleaf. But the Erin's HAD to ruin him and make him BAD! so I'm very very very very very very mad so yeah your decision erin hunter was terrible