no idea

with a pencil OH YOU MEAN ON FLIP roller

when im lazy i use the paint roller. otherwise I just put a layer over the color layer and tweak the original colors a bit so that its darker and has a cooler or warmer tint based on the lighting

I use the highlighter/marker thing and for example, ill use like, a dark magenta to shade blue, or a dark-blackish blue to shade black/very dark grey. Usually Pinkish-Red to shade skin- etc.

pencil use darkest color of the color ur already using (red = dark red) change pencil opacity (depends on how nice u want the shade) i use 0.1 then use the 6th tool to shade

I use a really dark black then I lower the opacity. I just use the pence. It works but as you can see on my art, it doesn't look very good when I do it.

Pencil and Paint Roller (Rarely).

i use the roll and use black for a black shade and white for a light shade

i grab the color of the area i want to shade, turn it a nocht darker, draw a line with the darker color on the surface, and pain inside the lie with the paint bucket

your account is not dead