![](http://flipanim.com/thumb/s/g/SGaj4VMS.jpg)
Violla :3
![](http://flipanim.com/thumb/i/p/IpeomoPx.jpg)
Cherry Blossom
![](http://flipanim.com/thumb/3/b/3BidfHft.jpg)
a random childhood story
![](http://flipanim.com/thumb/b/r/BR4qgobt.jpg)
Bob
![](http://flipanim.com/thumb/w/4/w4pY24mr.jpg)
Alphabet Animation!!
![](http://flipanim.com/thumb/0/a/0aolWK2u.jpg)
Papyrus believe in you
![](http://flipanim.com/thumb/u/e/UeoJ2Wek.jpg)
shark
Happy new editor! (update)
![](http://flipanim.com/gif/c/y/cY7w1lUM.gif)
![](http://assets.pinterest.com/images/pidgets/pinit_fg_en_rect_gray_20.png)
270 comments
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/sJKXTdCz_50.gif)
FlipAnim[OP]
31.12.2018 11:01
LinkHi animators! I'm happy to officially close no-update-2018 and (almost) start 2019 with brand new editor!
Click present icon on top bar, or navigate to http://flipanim.com/beta to try it now.
New editor is completely redone, with new features like:
-layers (and tools to copy/paste and hide them),
-ability to swap frames/layers (click/touch and hold),
-new UI with special version for big screen tablets/PCs,
-transform tools,
-vector graphics,
-delays/frames/layers tuning on live preview.
It's an beta version, so there's many features that are not yet implemented (like custom colors, fill tool, keyboard shortcuts), and editor can be pretty slow on detailed animations. But I'll be working on it, I'm promise! :D
Enjoy!
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/uzxjay3y.jpg)
PomegranatePanda
31.12.2018 11:10
LinkThank You! ❤️❤️ ✨
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/wf3w0t7t.jpg)
legojedi547634th
31.12.2018 12:43
LinkWoah the new editor looks awesome!!!:D
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/6knaj2zm.avatar.gif)
HolyHeccThatsGud
31.12.2018 14:05
Linky e e t u s
Comment removed
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/C5JkXnoW_50.gif)
conshh
31.12.2018 14:21
LinkYAY YOURE ACTIVE! and this is awesome! happy new year! :) ✨??
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/l19c18cd.avatar.gif)
Leelee607
31.12.2018 14:53
LinkThank you thank you !!!!!!
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/l19c18cd.avatar.gif)
Leelee607
31.12.2018 14:54
LinkHappy new year !
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/wFtO9iRk_50.gif)
Industriastar
31.12.2018 15:42
LinkThanks thanks tanks tanks tanks
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/wFtO9iRk_50.gif)
Industriastar
31.12.2018 15:42
LinkThanks thanks tanks tanks tanks
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/ghz7vvtq.jpg)
kidanimator
31.12.2018 15:48
LinkV-vector graphics?? Of to make some Happy Tree Friends!
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/YOVq3kFg_50.gif)
UmbreonxEspeonluvah
31.12.2018 15:50
LinkYOU ARE ALIVE OoO
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/wFtO9iRk_50.gif)
Industriastar
31.12.2018 16:11
LinkT
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/wFtO9iRk_50.gif)
Industriastar
31.12.2018 16:12
LinkA
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/wFtO9iRk_50.gif)
Industriastar
31.12.2018 16:12
LinkN
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/wFtO9iRk_50.gif)
Industriastar
31.12.2018 16:12
LinkK
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/wFtO9iRk_50.gif)
Industriastar
31.12.2018 16:12
LinkS
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/wFtO9iRk_50.gif)
Industriastar
31.12.2018 16:13
LinkThanks*
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/4XbilnkI_50.gif)
puper34
31.12.2018 16:16
Linkthe new editor looks noice
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/XNsX3HQU_50.gif)
raeraee
31.12.2018 16:18
LinkAwesome! Can't wait to experiment with it.
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/h4y5wrij.jpg)
FlamefurofNatureClan
31.12.2018 16:21
LinkWHAT HAPPENED @FlipAnim?!?!
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/w3vc4x6v.avatar.gif)
Dragon-in-a-Hoodie
31.12.2018 16:34
Linki was hoping for layers! :) thx flipanim. I thought u were dead or something.
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/5b9G4Lzn_50.gif)
WingsofFire123
31.12.2018 16:35
LinkThanks FlipAnim! We love it!
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/5b9G4Lzn_50.gif)
WingsofFire123
31.12.2018 16:44
LinkHappy New Years! ?
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/diygqqlv.jpg)
yuseilifluff
31.12.2018 17:25
Linkthank you and happy new year!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i love it but i like
custom colors but its very amazing on animating !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/czibljng_50.gif)
Velouria
31.12.2018 17:51
LinkYES! thank you very much flipanim! and happy new years!!!
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/ey6hxz64.avatar.gif)
fricklefracklefloof
31.12.2018 17:52
LinkTHIS IS A MAZING THANK YOU THANK YOUT AHNK YOU THANK YOU SO MUHC
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/kTIvXEwj_50.gif)
Happy9
31.12.2018 18:12
LinkI can't wait for 2020 update!
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/7ykbad5t.avatar.gif)
runealien
31.12.2018 18:27
LinkOMG YES!
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/kTIvXEwj_50.gif)
Happy9
31.12.2018 18:35
LinkHow do you use delay
Comment removed
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/kTIvXEwj_50.gif)
Happy9
31.12.2018 19:38
LinkFlipanim can you do a update for giving the not finish animation and still work on it and delete the not finished one when you're done
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/w4d5jwp2.avatar.gif)
BlackFire911
31.12.2018 20:06
LinkOkay so I see a big improvement in this. I know this is still in beta, but I think we can all agree on what we want to see improve in the editor.
1. We NEED a redo button. I'm tired of accidentally pressing he undo button and having to start over an entire process.
2. I'm feel like you are already working on this, but we need that color palette thing to choose custom colors. We can't live without it.
3. I'm sorry if this is a burden, but we need a customizable pencil size for each tool.
4. We need the tools from the previous editor, along with even more tools. That would make an opportunity for some top quality animation. I feel like you are working on this as well. :)
5. OH YEAH, and we need a transparency option in the color palette.
6. Moving the background would be essential, as well.
That's all I can think of for now. Doing all of this may take a long time. I'm sorry if it's too much, I just want to be able to do more with FlipAnim. Also, if you do this, there's no doubt that this
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/w4d5jwp2.avatar.gif)
BlackFire911
31.12.2018 20:06
Linkwebsite will become extremely popular.
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/w4d5jwp2.avatar.gif)
BlackFire911
31.12.2018 20:08
LinkThank you so much for the current improvements ^^. I'll enjoy them until the full version is out. Happy new year as well.
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/tfedtus2.avatar.gif)
Pie-master
31.12.2018 20:13
Link???????
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/chys5dab.jpg)
beanslythefox
31.12.2018 20:21
LinkFantastic! That's great news, thanks, flipanim!
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/w4d5jwp2.avatar.gif)
BlackFire911
31.12.2018 20:23
LinkOh yes.
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/w4d5jwp2.avatar.gif)
BlackFire911
31.12.2018 20:29
LinkWAIT UP.
7.I WOULD LOVE TO IMPORT MP3s and sound to animations.
8.We need to be able to use more than one file without clearing the entire animation.
9.I don't know how this would be possible, but defy the odds by allowing a collaboration feature as well. Please add these. This would make Flipanim the best website ever to most off us. Thank you. ^^
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/w4d5jwp2.avatar.gif)
BlackFire911
31.12.2018 20:40
LinkThen we could make Music Videos, Short Cartoons, Anime Inspired cartoons, AMVs, and more.
10. We need to upload bigger files.
11. Instead of uploading as gifs, please make them upload as mp4s instead (with a gif option if you want). This is so people can rewind and fast-foward without having to watch the longer animations all over again.
12. We also need rulers to make straight lines and perfect shapes. PLEASE.
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/w4d5jwp2.avatar.gif)
BlackFire911
31.12.2018 20:40
Linkof*
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/z3qx2qut.avatar.gif)
Warriorcats10000
31.12.2018 21:01
LinkWow
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/o7a49lld.jpg)
Haru-Zoldyck
31.12.2018 22:09
LinkYou listened to my move frames request...oh my god someone noticed me at the bottom of comments...yeeeee
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/73xaxomb.jpg)
KittyLovesArt
01.01.2019 00:11
Linkcool! please feature :3 it has 70+ likes
Comment removed
Comment removed
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/cu15796j.avatar.gif)
Omeger
01.01.2019 02:27
Linkeveryone replying this is just trying to get features
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/iaZ7sJQS_50.gif)
FluffyPuffKitty
01.01.2019 03:34
LinkSuggestion: texting tool for animation
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/k37ynjlt.jpg)
seanacoletta
01.01.2019 04:25
LinkI just tried it out and it’s amazing!
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/uzxjay3y.jpg)
PomegranatePanda
01.01.2019 05:16
Link@omeger
Nah
I just wanted to be first ;)
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/uzxjay3y.jpg)
PomegranatePanda
01.01.2019 05:16
LinkLike i was with the delete button XD
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/glm45sz7.avatar.gif)
Piskelo10
01.01.2019 06:49
LinkThanks flipanim! I was actually thinking about asking about a month ago to add a feature that let you edit strokes. Thank you so much, this is gonna be so helpful in the longrun!
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/h4y5wrij.jpg)
FlamefurofNatureClan
01.01.2019 08:11
Link@FlipAnim, could you add where we could make stickers? there could be a separate editor to make stickers, witch us animators could save to use in Anims. we could do watermarks, slogans, signatures, or just drawings. i feel like this would be a really sweet feature and my fellow animators would agree. i would be so happy if you took my advice. Thank you if you read this, @FlipAnim!
Comment removed
Comment removed
![](http://flipanim.com/thumb/9/b/9bxtqecy.jpg)
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/lsvhjrpy.jpg)
Smiling
01.01.2019 17:10
LinkThanks flipanim! I'm really looking forward to meet you. I also want to show some of my projects, like this one!
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/ycXGZvyP_50.gif)
Miniblob
01.01.2019 17:19
LinkHello Flipanim!!!!! (Can you look at my stuff)
![](http://flipanim.com/thumb/8/e/8euZCTqZ.jpg)
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/ycXGZvyP_50.gif)
Miniblob
01.01.2019 17:20
LinkFor example :)
Comment removed
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/ay72z353.jpg)
SmolPikawu
01.01.2019 18:01
LinkFLIPANIM IS NOT DEDDDDDDD!! PARTY PARTY YEH YEH YEH!!!! 2019 PEOPLE!!!!
![](http://flipanim.com/thumb/h/h/HhffOuQv.jpg)
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/szFcjDiN_50.gif)
jammy-dounut
01.01.2019 22:15
Linkhey could you maybe feature this person's art
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/9yLDfuAu_50.gif)
SCupcake
03.01.2019 23:57
LinkSo I'm using the paper feature to color as a sub for the paint bucket, and my top layer keeps on disappearing.
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/73xaxomb.jpg)
KittyLovesArt
04.01.2019 05:28
LinkHow do I edit a old anim?? Or an anim from the old maker?
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/JSHywP3E_50.gif)
Dragonlover162
04.01.2019 06:04
LinkThere's no paint.can
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/mCMIjoNK_50.gif)
thunderheart
13.01.2019 00:43
Linkcan we be able to make longer animations, ever?
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/QDC86wfd_50.gif)
MrTroll123
19.01.2019 03:43
LinkDid Flipanim just... do...
this?👌Circle finger game meme
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/bj1sxl1k.jpg)
SamanthaVera
19.01.2019 07:12
Linkty!
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/eYiTPTGP_50.gif)
ShortYogo
19.01.2019 13:30
LinkTHANK YOU about could you add in a fill in option? For the News one of course
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/eYiTPTGP_50.gif)
ShortYogo
19.01.2019 13:30
LinkBut* new*
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/EfdEF9K6_50.gif)
taxi-tabaxi
28.01.2019 02:24
Link😂👌
Comment removed
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/EfdEF9K6_50.gif)
taxi-tabaxi
28.01.2019 02:27
LinkWhy Flip flop.
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/Kcoyneq7_50.gif)
Cand-yy
28.01.2019 15:34
LinkSo, is there a fill in/bucket option, or am I just not seeing it?
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/easm5M10_50.gif)
BlueLegoCats
23.03.2019 16:15
Linkthe new editor needs fill in option
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/easm5M10_50.gif)
BlueLegoCats
23.03.2019 16:39
LinkMaybe there could be a smudge tool? I think it could be good for things.
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/ZaC0XQE5_50.gif)
Asian-Duck
15.04.2019 11:53
Linkdo you know how you, like,... ugh i forgot.
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/4XbilnkI_50.gif)
creanity
06.06.2020 14:00
Link👌👌👌👀
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/6521k210.jpg)
Moonstar
24.09.2020 18:49
Linkwhat is a vector graphic???
also i think (and i have no idea im not a professional) that sound might be too big for the website's load thingie. maybe no sound, this is also a GIF maker; gifs don't have sound. However, @BlueLegoCats, a smudge tool would be awesome uwu
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/r7zo6y72.jpg)
TheRealDarkShadow
09.10.2020 22:06
Link@Moonstar vector graphics keep away blur. They are much better quality. It's like the animation program, flash.
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/cqebdhdc.jpg)
tonsn002307
14.09.2021 17:41
LinkOl
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/cqebdhdc.jpg)
tonsn002307
14.09.2021 17:41
LinkOk
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/fUGNFgDe_50.gif)
Woah cool new editor but little bit hard... uh nothing! HAPPY NEW 2019 YEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR!!!!!!! PARTY PARTY PARTY! 2019!
Comment removed
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/72wuotjp.jpg)
Happy New Year!
Thank you so much for this amazing update!
It’s absolutely amazing and you must have really worked hard on it so thank you so much! ^-^
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/Rd8s3aww_50.gif)
Dude, it's cool, but it'd be great if you could make the layout closer to the current one. I don't want to have to spend a bunch of time relearning how to use the site.
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/Rd8s3aww_50.gif)
Since apparently I'm the only one with any real feedback:
The new layout looks kind of clutterd. Like, all the tools and colours are in differnt places. I like the settings menu just being some icons to the side, but the colours all being just out there instead of the little folder thing kinda looks... ugly, I guess.
Also, the layout being pretty different from the older one will make it pretty hard for everyone to get used to it. A more similar set up would def be beneficial.
In my opinion, but, y'know.
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/7ie27el7.jpg)
the update is awesome, and right on time lol im making the eyes half closed meme and i needed an editing tool
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/ogqmqy04.jpg)
GET OUT
NO
NO
D E AD
BGFTVF
the only sad part is now this doesn't feel like a 'flipbook' animation site..
that's what it was supposed to be but we kept saying to change stuff and add stuff and i didn't realize how different that'd make our good ol' flipanim.
this looks ama z ing
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/LfKF1sDZ_50.gif)
am i the only one who noticed the OK sign?! AND THE FRIGGIN MLG CRYING EMOJI THING WHATEVER ITS NAME IS lmao
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/pubhoxek.avatar.gif)
Is this going to replace the regular way, or will it be an option to use it when the update is finished?
Comment removed
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/vkzT0BCb_50.gif)
Its the best! Thank you so much! Have a awesome new year! My mum's B-day is on new years lol
Just one request or two....
Can you work on the fill tool/color pallet? It'll help so much please and thank you!
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/mcbwu3mg.jpg)
hi, yes uh i was wondering about a bug. when you make something and make the certain time then when you post it, it goes faster. its pretty annoying but i was just saying just in case ya didnt know. ok bye bye
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/thumb/vqri4r2f.jpg)
Hey, if this sounds rude I am VERY sorry but could you please add a recorder or something to add sound? I understand if you can't
Comment removed
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/GSsyF9AI_50.gif)
I dislike this new update,its very confusing and I would like if you added a paint bucket,not going outside the lines like so it stays in and doesn’t overlap the original drawing,and I would to know how this new update works,and please keep the old drawing,the one with the pencil button still there so people can have a easier drawing place and the 2019 version for others who want to try it out,UwU
![](http://storage.gra.cloud.ovh.net/v1/AUTH_728ab22ba0c842468a897907be9a7075/flipanim/avatar/ewdrndn7.avatar.gif)
Thanks so much for the new animator!! Its amazing and looks like it must have taken a lot of work..
I know you are getting a lot of requests and I feel kind of bad but I would like to make one as well. On the old animator I can press Ctrl Z to undo something but with the newer one I am not able to, it makes things a lot faster for me. So if possible and assuming you even see this could you make Ctrl Z work on the other animator as well? I would greatly appreciate it.
But thanks again for the new animator! :)
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/5168KEEH_50.gif)
Still could use some improvements. I used to use these methods back in the 90s. Are you one of those inside new order people?
http://flipanim.com/anim=9oJ5XuqR
://www.deviantart.com/nightphoenix2/art/X-Men-Vol-2-No-22-1993-D-395757020
Were you connected with the folks at aniboom?
https://www.deviantart.com/nightphoenix2/art/Superman-VS-Goku-Aniboom-again-297198375?ga_submit_new=10%3A1546629045&ga_type=edit&ga_changes=1
![](http://flipanim.com/avatars/5168KEEH_50.gif)
Still could use some improvements. I used to use these methods back in the 90s. Are you one of those inside new order people?
http://flipanim.com/anim=9oJ5XuqR
://www.deviantart.com/nightphoenix2/art/X-Men-Vol-2-No-22-1993-D-395757020
Were you connected with the folks at aniboom?
https://www.deviantart.com/nightphoenix2/art/Superman-VS-Goku-Aniboom-again-297198375?ga_submit_new=10%3A1546629045&ga_type=edit&ga_changes=1